- “Bicuspid! I found it! The treasure of Crocodile Creek. A golden crocodile tooth!”
- ―Captain Hook
Role in the series
The Golden Crocodile Tooth first appeared in the episode "Tick Tock Trap", Captain Hook tricks Brewster the Beast Trapper into capturing and riding Never Land of Tick-Tock the Crocodile, allowing Hook to finally be free of the dreaded reptile and claim the treasure at the bottom of Crocodile Creek. Unknown to Hook and his crew at the time Jake and his crew overhear Hook's plot and were determined to convince Brewster that the croc belongs in Never Land and that Hook is the real threat. Brewster finally gets the upper hand by using an alarm clock to lure Tick-Tock into a cage aboard his boat. Jake and his crew finally confront Brewster, pleading with him not to take the croc away, and that Hook is only using Brewster to claim the treasure at the bottom of Crocodile Creek. Brewster was a little wary to trust the young pirates since he was warned earlier by Hook about them. But sensing the young pirates care so deeply for wildlife, Brewster realizes the young pirates speak the truth and agreed to let the crocodile go. Unknown to Brewster, Mr. Smee, Sharky and Bones try to escape with Brewster's boat and the crocodile. But Brewster, with the assistance of Jake and his crew, reclaim his ship after freeing Tick-Tock. Meanwhile, Captain Hook was further downstream, believing Brewster has finally rid him of the cursed crocodile. Hook discovers the golden crocodile tooth at the bottom of the Crocodile Creek but this is short-lived when Brewster captures the captain, leaving him dangling over the creek and at the mercy of Tick-Tock. When attempting to devour Hook, he rips a hole at the bottom of Hook's butterfly net-hook releasing the golden tooth back into the creek. The Golden Crocodile Tooth is last seen at the end of the episode, Tick-Tock is fast asleep after his many attempts to devour Captain Hook failed, giving Mr. Smee, Sharky, and Bones the opportunity to rescue Hook, but the croc soon wakes causing the pirates to flee in terror dropping Hook on top of the crocodile's snout who quickly flees behind his crew in terror. As Tick-Tock chuckles at the terrified pirates it reveals the golden crocodile tooth is now safe within Tick-Tock's mouth.
- The Golden Crocodile Tooth is the second treasure at the bottom of Crocodile Creek since the Golden Fishing Poles from the episode Cubby's Sunken Treasure.